A History of Racism |
Overviews |
The Nineteenth Century |
America |
Recent Times |
Return to 'More Links' page |
Return to main index |
|
Overviews |
Famine Unit II: Racism Nebraska Department of Education |
Massacres, the
slave trade, and the theft of vast tracts of other people's land, have all been
justified by claims of religious, cultural and racial superiority. Such myths
often hide the harsh reality of exploitation and colonization. Anti-Irish
prejudice is a very old theme in English culture. The written record begins
with Gerald of Wales, whose family was deeply involved in the Norman invasion
of |
|
Anti-Irish racism Wikipedia |
Negative
English attitudes to Irish culture and habits date as far back as the reign of
Henry II and the Norman conquest of |
|
Racism and Prejudice Moving here |
The
Anthropological Review and Journal of 1866 claimed that "Gaelic man"
was characterised by "his bulging jaw and lower part of the face,
retreating chin and forehead, large mouth and thick lips, great distance
between nose and mouth, upturned nose, prominent cheekbones, sunken eyes,
projecting eyebrows, narrow elongated skull and protruding ears". This
sort of "scientific" racism was not uncommon in the nineteenth
century and was also directed against Jewish and African people. "Without
intending offence", stated an article on the London Irish in Blackwood's
Edinburgh Magazine of July 1901, "we would point to this common feature in
the Hibernian and Negro idiosyncrasy, that a dull manhood follows upon a youth
of the highest promise". This "no offence, but -" introductory
remark always heralds a statement that will be offensive and is one commonly
experienced by migrant groups. Similar
attitudes often lie behind anti-Irish jokes which stereotype Irish people as
stupid or ridicule their accents, as in the |
|
'Nothing but the Same Old Story' (Book review) Amazon: UK and US |
[This book] was published with support by the Greater London Council as an educational
effort in the early 1980's after more than a decade of virulent anti-Irish
feeling in
|
|
Anti-Irish quotes throughout history Politics.ie |
They live on beasts only, and live like beasts. They have not
progressed at all from the habits of pastoral living. ..This is a
filthy people, wallowing in vice. Of all peoples it is the least
instructed in the rudiments of the faith. They do not yet pay tithes or
first fruits or contract marriages. They do not avoid incest. |
|
A View of the State of Ireland Edmund Spenser (Google Books) |
Marry those be the most barbaric and loathy conditions of any people (I think) under heaven...They do use all the beastly behaviour that may be, they oppress all men, they spoil as well the subject, as the enemy; they steal, they are cruel and bloody, full of revenge, and delighting in deadly execution, licentious, swearers and blasphemers, common ravishers of women, and murderers of children.[...] And first I have to find fault with the abuse of language; that is, for the speaking of Irish among the English, which as it is unnatural that any people should love another's language more than their own, so it is very inconvenient and the cause of many other evils. ...It seemeth strange to me that the English should take more delight to speak that language than their own, whereas they should, methinks, rather take scorn to acquaint their tongues thereto. For it hath ever been the use of the conqueror to despise the language of the conquered and to force him by all means to learn his. |
|
Dictionary of Race and Ethnic Relations Ernest Cashmore, Michael Banton (Google Books) |
The
Irish emigrant experience can only be understood by recognising the dramatic
impact that centuries of British colonialism has had for the Irish people. As a
result of its geographical position and internal political feuds |
|
Out of Africa, out of Ireland Rootsweb |
In Black Folk Then and Now, Du Bois
concurs: "Even young Irish peasants were hunted down as men hunt down
game, and were forcibly put aboard ship, and sold to plantations in According to Peter
Berresford Ellis in To Hell or Connaught,
soldiers commanded by Henry Cromwell, Oliver's son, seized a thousand
"Irish wenches" to sell to
|
|
The Love of the Irish Slate |
|
|
Return to top |
|
Racism in the Nineteenth Century |
'A perverse and ill-fated people: English perceptions of the Irish 1845-52' University of Virginia (Link no longer available) |
The
150th anniversary of the Irish potato famine in autumn 1996 is already stirring
a highly emotional reappraisal of the history of English treatment of
|
|
The Irish Famine: An Act of Providence? BBC |
Finally,
we come to 'moralism'-the notion that the fundamental defects from which the
Irish suffered were moral rather than financial. Educated Britons of this era
saw serious defects in the Irish 'national character'-disorder or violence,
filth, laziness, and worst of all, a lack of self-reliance. This amounted to a
kind of racial or cultural stereotyping. The Irish had to be taught to stand on
their own feet and to unlearn their dependence on government. |
|
Racism and anti-Irish prejudice in Victorian England Victorian Web |
In
much of the pseudo-scientific literature of the day the Irish were held to be
inferior, an example of a lower evolutionary form, closer to the apes than their
"superiors", the Anglo-Saxons. Cartoons in Punch portrayed the Irish
as having bestial, ape-like or demonic features and the Irishman, (especially
the political radical) was invariably given a long or prognathous jaw[…] Even
seemingly complimentary generalizations about the Irish national character
could, in the Victorian context, be damaging to the Celt. Thus, following the
work of Ernest Renan's La Poésie des Races Celtiques
(1854), it was broadly argued that the Celt was poetic, light-hearted and
imaginative, highly emotional, playful, passionate, and sentimental. But these
were characteristics the Victorians also associated with children. |
|
Nineteenth century caricatures of the Irish Haverford College |
Note the attention given to racial "types" in the prognathous or "simian" jawline, and the constant identification of both the Irish and the African as similarly constucted and inferior. |
|
The Politics of Irish Literature The Astonisher |
Discreetly,
the famished dead seldom crossed [Thomas Carlyle's] line of vision, but beggars were
everywhere, approaching him at every crossroads with clever simulations of
hunger. He was not born yesterday, and divil a halfpenny their tricks ever got
from him.[...] It
was not Repeal of the |
|
British Women Playwrights Around 1800 University of Montreal |
The
central plot of The Sons of Erin is fairly straightforward. Emily
Rivers, whose extended family is virulently anti-Irish, eloped with Arthur Fitz
Edward in the wake of her mother's death and her father's remarriage to a much
younger woman. Having frittered away his inheritance and lost his job as a
member of the Irish Parliament when it was abolished by the Act of Union
(1800), Fitz Edward is in financial straits that only Emily's wealthy family
can resolve--but they have disowned her for marrying an Irishman.[…] The play's
handling of prejudice received much attention in the reviews. The Lady's
Monthly Museum praises its "direct moral tendency" to eliminate
anti-Irish prejudice and The Examiner cites "the laudable and
seasonable intention of the fair writer to do away with the lingering
prejudices with regard to the character of her countrymen”. |
|
Anti-Irish racism and the Convict Era Socialist Alternative |
Irish convicts
were singled out for especially harsh punishment. Seventy per cent
of Irish convicts were transported for their first offence, mainly petty theft.
But when convicts from
|
|
Popular Anti-Catholicism in Mid-Victorian England Denis G. Paz (Google Books) |
|
|
Punch magazine anti-Irish cartoon: Young Ireland Punch magazine anti-Irish cartoon: Fenians Wikipedia Punch magazine cartoons: Daniel O'Connell, the Famine and the Easter Rising Irish Historian Rear Window: Punch Lines that Kept the Irish in their Place: Taking the Mick Independent FECKLESS, stupid, drunken, combative and relentlessly talkative, the Irishmen of Victorian Punch cartoons merge together into a stereotype that has proved enduring. Former colleagues of Trevor McAuley at Auto Alloys Foundry in Blackwell, Derbyshire, had similar ideas about the Irish. 'Typical thick Paddy,' they said, and 'That's Irish logic' and 'What else can you expect from an Irishman?'. Mr McAuley (who happens to come from the heart of Paisleyite Co Antrim and describes himself firmly as British) won pounds 5,900 damages last week after satisfying an industrial tribunal that such remarks, endlessly repeated in the workplace, amounted to racist abuse. He was the fourth Irish person to win a case of this kind in the past year. Contempt for Irish people and their habits has a long history in Britain. Gerald of Wales, visiting Ireland in the 1180s, wrote of a barbarous, filthy and irresponsible people who 'think that the greatest pleasure is not to work'. In the 17th century, Fynes Moryson lamented the squalor and drunkenness of Irish life, even in the Anglicised towns of Dublin and Cork. His rooms, he noted, 'were scarce swept once in a week, and the dust then laid in a corner was perhaps cast out once in a month or two'. But it was surely Punch and its satirical rivals in the 19th century that sculpted the foolish, idle figure of fun whose descendants stand behind the Auto Alloys insults and the Irish jokes of today.[...] To English readers who knew the Irish only as rootless, troublesome navvies, small-time terrorists or the distant, lumpen victims of famine or rural hardship, it was doubtless reassuring to learn that these people were prodigal idiots. If they were poor or hungry, or if their homes and their countryside were overcrowded, it was because they refused to improve themselves. Money or sympathy, it was clear, would be wasted on them. |
|
Catherine Hall, Keith McClelland, Jane Rendall (Google Books)
|
Simply
being Irish meant being associated with Fenianism, whether there was any
evidence of nationalist sentiment or not.[…] But there was also deep hostility
to the movement, a hostility that became more widespread in the aftermath of
the ‘outrages’ on the mainland.[…] Fenianism fostered the most inflammatory
image of the Irish, the subversive within, the terrorist potentially rotting
the vitals of the nation. |
Return to top |
|
The Irish in America |
The Irish, the Blacks and the Struggle with Racism (Book review) The Boston Globe |
Many
immigrant groups in the |
|
Anti-Irish Sentiment Heidelberg University |
On arrival in |
|
No Irish Need Apply: A Myth of Victimisation Richard Jensen, University of Illinois |
Irish Catholics in |
|
Gone to America History Place |
There were only a limited number of unskilled jobs available.
Intense rivalry quickly developed between the Irish and working class
Bostonians over these jobs. In In |
|
How the Irish Became White University of Dayton |
Ironically, Irish Catholics came to this country as an oppressed race yet quickly learned that to succeed they had to in turn oppress their closest social class competitors, free Northern blacks. Back home these "native Irish or papists" suffered something very similar to American slavery under English Penal Laws. Yet, despite their revolutionary roots as an oppressed group fighting for freedom and rights, and despite consistent pleas from the great Catholic emancipator, Daniel O'Connell, to support the abolitionists, the newly arrived Irish-Americans judged that the best way of gaining acceptance as good citizens and to counter the Nativist movement was to cooperate in the continued oppression of African Americans. […] Irish and Africans Americans had lots in common and lots of contact during this period; they lived side by side and shared work spaces. […] The Irish were often referred to as "Negroes turned inside out and Negroes as smoked Irish." A famous quip of the time attributed to a black man went something like this: "My master is a great tyrant, he treats me like a common Irishman." |
|
Irish in America YouTube (Luftwaffels) |
In
the mid 1800s, many Irishmen and women travelled to |
|
Introduction to Nativism Historical Society of Pennsylvania |
Nativist feelings toward the Irish in the early 19th century had their roots in anti-Irish stereotypes inherited from Britain but took on an American flavor in the form of concerns about the threat that the Irish and other Catholic immigrants (including some from Germany) were seen to pose to American democracy, attitudes that were held by prominent men such as Horace Bushnell and Samuel Morse. The popular belief was that the Catholic faith bound the Irish in loyalty to Pope and foreign monarchies.
|
New Evidence Suggests 57 Irish Railroad Workers were murdered Irish Independent |
US historians trying to uncover a mystery surrounding the mass death of 57 Irish immigrants nearly 180 years ago, have found evidence they may have been murdered.[...] Four skulls unearthed from the mass grave suggest the men suffered blows to the head and at least one may have been shot in an outpouring of anti-Irish violence.[...] Dr Watson [of Immaculata University] said the revelation that at least four of the men had died violent deaths proved "this was much more than a cholera epidemic". Anti-Irish feelings ran high in 19th Century America. |
Return to top |
|
Recent Times |
Written answers - anti-Irish racism Dáil Éireann |
The
Irish Government has welcomed the report's highlighting of the extent of the
particular difficulties, based on prejudice or discrimination, which Irish
people frequently encounter in
|
|
Nothing but the Same Old Story? Britain's wars on Irish and Islamic Terror Left Curve |
It seemed only yesterday that British
newspapers were churning out an unrelenting diet of vicious anti-Irish cartoons
at the height of another War on Terror, conducted by the British state from the
1970s to the 1990s, or for the duration of what is euphemistically known as “the
Troubles.” Many of these were of a sexual or religious nature, depicting the Irish
as having a highly developed taste for anarchy and violence, as well as a
propensity for ‘thickness’ or stupidity. Word on the Irish street in
|
|
A classic case of an English Historian Manchester Irish (Article referred to: The Evil Legacy of the Easter Rising, Guardian) |
Geoffrey
Wheatcroft had a scurrilous piece in the Observer newspaper last week entitled
'The evil legacy of the Easter Rising'. Great to see some superb replies in
this week's copy of the paper including thisthisone from Kevin Daly, "...Wheatcroft
needs to read a copy of the Proclamation of the Irish Republic and take a
closer look at the beliefs and objectives of Irish republicanism from 1798
onwards before making cheap allegations against a group of determined and
committed men and women who sought to free their nation from a foreign
oppressor. This is a classic case of an English 'historian' patronising the
people of a former colony". |
|
Writer's anti-Irish column branded racist Irish Independent Unruly Julie: Julie Burchill Business Post |
POLICE
in The outspoken
columnist, whose reputation rests on voicing views designed to provoke, aired
her opinion of Irish society with special reference to the Catholic Church -
prompting John Twomey, a social worker at the London Irish centre, to complain
to police that the article had contravened the Race Relations Act. Referring to the St Patrick's Day parade, Burchill questioned the money being spent by London mayor Ken Livingstone, suggesting it was to "celebrate almost compulsory child molestation by the national church, total discrimination against women who wish to be priests, aiding and abetting Hitler in his hour of need and outlawing abortion and divorce." |
|
Many Scots 'still face sectarian abuse' BBC |
Sectarian abuse remains a widespread problem in "In |
|
Irish fire worker claims racism Irish fire worker wins race claim BBC |
An Irish woman who was told her race was "a
sin" by a fire service colleague has won £3,000 in compensation. At the hearing in March she said that in
January 2003, watch commander Liz Mitchell told her to leave if she didn't
"start speaking the Queen's English". […] Ms Neylan also claimed she
was victimised on 7 and |
|
It wasn't sectarianism, your honour: the Taigs provoked me BBC |
Take the loyal citizens who tore down a Tyrone GAA flag from a house in Coleraine last week, wrapped it round a brick and fired it through the living room window, then returned two nights later and fired shots into the house. Sectarian? "Oh no," they might say, "that flag was hung out there to alienate and intimidate us. We are the victims here." |
|
Anti-Irish Racism in Britain Sinn Féin |
Sinn
Féin's resolute opposition to racism is in the context of the experience by
many Irish people of anti-Irish racism. Sinn Féin will campaign vigorously to
encourage the Irish Government, and other governments - especially the British
Government - to assume their responsibilities for addressing continuing
anti-Irish racism in |
|
Phoebe Prince case New York Times Ms. Prince’s family had recently moved to the United States from a
small town in Ireland, and she entered South Hadley last fall. The
taunting started when she had a brief relationship with a popular
senior boy; some students reportedly called her an “Irish slut,”
knocked books out of her hands and sent her threatening
, day after day.BBC's Newsnight Accused of Racism Irish Independent The BBC's Newsnight
programme has been accused of "racist" stereotyping over a bulletin
about Britain's role in the international bail-out for Ireland.
Viewers complained that scenes depicting a cut-out of British Chancellor George Osborne dancing across sepia images of the Irish countryside were offensive. Comments by Mr Osborne about supporting the country through its financial crisis also flashed on the screen in a Celtic font to the sound of traditional Irish music.[...] Message boards and social networking sites were awash with angry comments condemning the coverage as 'bad taste' and 'condescending'. |